Battle of the Davids

Posted on: May 20, 2008 at 9:57 pm | Posted under: Entertainment, Television
Tags: , , ,

Tonight’s final performance episode of American Idol was one of the best that I have seen so far.  Both David Cook and David Archuleta are deserving of being in the final two.  All season long both contestants have performed at a higher caliber than the others and that was evident tonight.

David Cook is amazingly talented and has the voice of this generation, my generation.  His vocal performances are amazing and always manage to surprise me at every show.  He is destined to go far, even if he does not win tomorrow night.  American Idol is about talent, and to put it simply, he has it.

David Archuleta is a very gifted adolescent that has proved himself to be a contender in this competition.  He has a large following of teen & tween girls, and given his age this is no surprise.  I do not see him being able to handle the pressures that will come after this competition is over.  His father is always meddling in what he sings and was even banned by the producers from working with David.  That is saying a lot, given how lenient Nigel Lythgoe is with what happens behind the scenes.  After having dinner with some friends earlier tonight, they said that this whole issue may have ruined things for David.

Now I am one to believe that America’s votes do not have the final say in who is eliminated each week or who will win this season.  If you have watched the show regularly all season, then you will know that certain contestants were eliminated at key times, mostly stemming from controversy with something from their past or behind the scenes.  I have my theories about this, and I may be totally wrong.  Conspiracies are fun :)

Ok, let me wrap this up.  David Cook should be the next American Idol, he is the voice of this generation and has more talent than the competition.  Archuleta doesn’t have the maturity to handle this competition and his family is ruining things for him.

Tomorrow night will reveal our American Idol, and I hope it’s David Cook.

Cheers!

2 Comments »
  • http://pawtrait04.blogspot.com/ Paul Fletcher

    David Cook held true to his musical soul and that will cost him dearly. His music, even though I like it better was too unknown for the vast voting public. To me his U2 won the first round and his Collective Soul cover was infinitely better than David A’s butchering of Imagine (you can tell my age by the fact that I had to do an analysis of a current song in school – and I picked that!)

  • http://pawtrait04.blogspot.com/ Paul Fletcher

    David Cook held true to his musical soul and that will cost him dearly. His music, even though I like it better was too unknown for the vast voting public. To me his U2 won the first round and his Collective Soul cover was infinitely better than David A’s butchering of Imagine (you can tell my age by the fact that I had to do an analysis of a current song in school – and I picked that!)